A tribute announcement names both the people playing and the music they plan to explore. Confusing those two roles can turn an old search result into a false concert credit. Phoncert’s surviving pages make the distinction especially useful: one bill draws on Herbie Hancock’s music, another describes an LCD Soundsystem tribute, and Runaway Gin introduces a project inspired by Phish.
These are historical descriptions of the advertised projects. They do not establish that the original artists appeared, which songs were performed, or that playable recordings have survived here.
The Herbie Hancock tribute: the advertised players
The announcement names Dave Watts, Joey Porter and Garrett Sayers of The Motet, Dominic Lalli of Big Gigantic, and Dan Schwindt of Kyle Hollingsworth Band. It describes an exploration of Hancock’s 1970s repertoire with improvisation and extended solos. Herbie Hancock is the source of the repertoire; he is not named as a performer on this bill.
- 394: Cervantes Masterpiece Ballroom; displayed 15 August 2014, 4:30AM. Preserved announcement.
- 395: the same venue and displayed date, 5:00AM. Preserved announcement.
The two biographies are the same. A thirty-minute difference between cards does not establish two sets, two concerts or a change of musicians. Nor does the broad 1970s description justify inserting familiar song titles into a reconstructed set list.
North American Scum: a tribute identity wider than one act
The biography on card 260 calls North American Scum an LCD Soundsystem tribute and says the group has also played Nirvana and Talking Heads shows. That is a description of the project’s range. The page does not say which of those repertoires was performed during this event.
There is a date discrepancy worth keeping visible. The card displays The 1up Colfax, 7 December 2014 at 6:15AM. The catalogue captured in October 2014 links the same number to 6 December 2014 at 7:00PM. The sources do not explain the difference. We preserve both values without choosing a local time or inventing a rescheduling story.
A useful research note would start “North American Scum — The 1up Colfax — card 260,” then retain both displayed dates with their sources. If a recording is later identified, its verified local date can be added separately. Labelling it only “LCD Soundsystem” would erase the distinction between interpreting another band’s material and being that band.
Runaway Gin: improvisation as part of the stated purpose
The artist page preserved in July 2014 describes Runaway Gin as Phish fans making music inspired by the band. It emphasises an expanding repertoire, improvisation and musical communication, and mentions a Sunday residency at the Charleston Pour House. That residency is historical context; the page is not a current timetable.
Unlike the numbered cards, this is an artist introduction. It supplies no individual Phoncert show number or concert date. Its promise that performances will differ is the band’s declared approach, not a comparison we have made between recordings.
For a listener, that approach suggests a question beyond simple likeness: how does a familiar song become the starting point for a new passage? In a verified recording, compare where the melody returns and how the group moves into or out of it. This is an editorial listening prompt, not evidence about a particular Runaway Gin performance.
Pink Talking Fish: arranging connections between three catalogues
The Pink Talking Fish card, 611, names Buffalo Iron Works and displays 5 March 2015 at 2:30AM. Its historical introduction describes a project joining music by Pink Floyd, Talking Heads and Phish. It names Eric Gould on bass, Richard James on keyboards and Zack Burwick on drums, alongside a changing cast of other musicians.
The useful detail is how the band describes the arrangement: one composition can become a passage inside another, or pieces from different repertoires can form a connected sequence. This is a more specific purpose than playing one artist’s songs in isolation. The examples in the biography illustrate the project’s approach; they are not a recovered set list for this concert.
The Buffalo producer’s recording reference identifies 4 March 2015. Preserve that attribution alongside the card’s display without inventing a time-zone conversion. A reference to a recording and a generic artist biography answer different questions: which performance is being identified, and what kind of project was advertised?
DeadPhish Orchestra: a short bill with specific names
492: Cervantes Masterpiece Ballroom; 18 January 2015, 4:30AM. The brief card presents a combination of Phish and Grateful Dead material and names Chris Sheldon on drums, Paul Murin on guitar, Brian Adams on bass and Ted Tilton on keyboards, with vocals credited to all four.
Those are the musicians named in this introduction, rather than members of Phish or the Grateful Dead appearing under another heading. The source does not identify songs, transitions between them or the length of the performance. Its brevity is a reason to preserve the useful credits, not to invent a set list.
Critt’s Juke Joint: a named programme, not a single-artist credit
The Buffalo.FM Presents Critt’s Juke Joint card names Buffalo Iron Works and displays 27 September 2015 at 1:00AM. Its short description calls the programme Songs in the Key of Love, names Stevie Wonder’s music among its contents, and gives Saturday 26 September.
The adjacent dates may be understandable in the context of evening concerts and after-midnight displays, but the recovered card does not specify a time zone. Keep the programme’s stated Saturday and the card’s timestamp as separate fields. It advertises Critt’s Juke Joint performing music associated with Wonder and others, not a Stevie Wonder appearance.
Credit the interpretation as well as the repertoire
Across these six descriptions, three pieces of information do different jobs: the performing act, the musical reference and the individual event. Keep all three when identifying a recording. An affectionate tribute can be artistically distinctive; accurate attribution lets the listener discover the people doing the interpreting.
For the Motet’s own listings, continue to the funk and fusion cards. For other repeated identifiers and collaborations, read the Jen Hartswick Superjam comparison.
